Chinese Ceramics & Antiques Discussion

Antique Chinese Ceramics => Chinese Ceramics Discussion => Topic started by: T. Chan on May 24, 2014, 15:20:38

Title: Stand jar with cover marked 'Daoguang'
Post by: T. Chan on May 24, 2014, 15:20:38
Hi everyone, i have just bought it a year ago, a stand jar with cover marked 'Daoguang'. I like it because it is so colorful but I don't know if this from the same period or later? Is this an export ware? The 'dragon' on the sides are strangely drawn, no printed drawing and the paste a little yellowish brown. Is this made in Jingdezhen? The color is match and foot rim has been cleaned. Height 46cm.
Thanks.
Title: Re: Stand jar with cover marked 'Daoguang'
Post by: T. Chan on May 24, 2014, 15:23:50
Have to slit into two since too colorful takes up kilobytes.
Title: Re: Stand jar with cover marked 'Daoguang'
Post by: calder on May 24, 2014, 16:03:00
Hi  T. Chan.
What a wonderful detailed vase.
sorry I cant Help.
Title: Re: Stand jar with cover marked 'Daoguang'
Post by: T. Chan on May 24, 2014, 20:48:04
Hi Calder, yes it is detail and very very colorful but there are several errors on the Buddhist cross pattern like the one on the last picture. The one that makes me wonder is why the paste is not white like all Jingdezhen wares. Hope Peter or Stan can help with this.
Title: Re: Stand jar with cover marked 'Daoguang'
Post by: T. Chan on May 25, 2014, 14:02:37
So sorry, I just realize that I havent post the picture that has Daoguang mark.
Title: Re: Stand jar with cover marked 'Daoguang'
Post by: peterp on May 25, 2014, 14:51:28
The inside of the stem/foot rim look too smooth in the picture showing these. A closer shot could show if the clay is really that dense. If yes, the clay was probably factory prepared.
Title: Re: Stand jar with cover marked 'Daoguang'
Post by: Stan on May 25, 2014, 15:27:35
Hi everyone, Peter is right this is a modern item, I do not think that the mark is Daoguang, I don't know what it is, I was told by an expert that Chinese antique porcelain that is genuine and signed with an Imperial reign mark in the Zhuanshu script across the vase would be worth millions, they are that rare, so when you see one the chances of it being real is like playing the lottery. and I never win, but the shape is also modern.
Title: Re: Stand jar with cover marked 'Daoguang'
Post by: T. Chan on May 26, 2014, 03:25:29
I am not at home now. When i got home, maybe in a week time, i will take a macro pic of the base and post it.  But in the mean time, do you know why the paste is yellowish and not white? Have you come across a genuine Qing antique with such paste? This paste is realy very suspicious. But this jar is consider light compare to others.
Btw, Stan, about the across mark, I just know it today, from you, that it is very rare. I thought it was the same with base mark.
Now i can only post a crop pic of the base, but its not very clear. Thanks.
Title: Re: Stand jar with cover marked 'Daoguang'
Post by: peterp on May 26, 2014, 07:49:26
Yes, the paste is a bit too yellow. That is indeed a Daoguang mark, but I know of no instances where such horizontal marks were used in the Daoguang period. Not all periods had marks on the outside of an item.
Title: Re: Stand jar with cover marked 'Daoguang'
Post by: T. Chan on Jun 03, 2014, 21:18:24
Hi Peter, Here are several macro pics of the paste taken from inside and outside. Hope these will help. Thanks.
Title: Re: Stand jar with cover marked 'Daoguang'
Post by: Stan on Jun 03, 2014, 22:05:55
Hi T Chan, great pictures, Peter could you define yellow, because I am having a hard time seeing it, it looks a little reddish to me.
Title: Re: Stand jar with cover marked 'Daoguang'
Post by: Stan on Jun 03, 2014, 22:08:21
Or maybe orange.
Title: Re: Stand jar with cover marked 'Daoguang'
Post by: peterp on Jun 04, 2014, 07:29:28
The paste on the newer pictures looks normal, except that a bit too many impurities are enclosed. But still, I don't think it is antique. The decoration looks like something from the 20th century. Very elaborate painting...
Title: Re: Stand jar with cover marked 'Daoguang'
Post by: T. Chan on Jun 04, 2014, 22:36:26
Dear Peter and Stan, I think the color of the paste should be a little more yellowish reddish brown? Here I post another pic which I think the color is match now.
I think the paste definately not from Jindezhen? Yes could be from 20th century because the green foo lion is too childish?
Title: Re: Stand jar with cover marked 'Daoguang'
Post by: Stan on Jun 05, 2014, 22:16:49
With photo's like these it is easy to evaluate, others should follow suit.